Silence is (not) Golden.
The sport of motocross is a strange one to be sure, often times you can watch and baseball or hockey game and feel pretty confident that you can review a players performance fairly and accurately. But...
What you see out on the field is what it is, meaning either the player hits the ball, scores a goal or he doesn’t. If the player is hurt and battling something significant, the announcers let us in on it and we cut him some slack for his performance or think that he is awesome for fighting through something.
Not so in motocross. We don’t have extensive media coverage and the teams are not an open book for all of us to read. We don’t know what the riders going through with his body, we don’t know if the bike wasn’t working or was on the verge of breaking. We in the media have to guesstimate what we think is going on with a rider or team. Think about this, how many one on one interviews do you see on ESPN.com? Yet you click on any moto site you want and there is the athlete telling us the fans what is going on with him and his bike, season-whatever. We have to just believe him when he says he’s hurt, there’s no team physician or whatever telling us what is up with a rider. And the flip side is true also, if no one tracks down a rider then we don’t know the reason for his big fade or even worse, no show.
For example if you went to Toronto and watched the 450 main event, you saw Andrew Short grab third place and stay there for about half the race before fading badly to the back. It was a performance that you wouldn’t normally see out of Andrew and had to have made some of the 30,000+ fans questioning what in the hell was wrong with Andrew. I can guarantee you that some fans thought he was out of shape, some thought he had no heart and was just riding for a paycheck while some others were sure that he just didn’t have it on this night. Actually, none of those are true as during the first practice, Andrew tore his tricep muscle and was in pain the whole night. When he got into third, he knew he couldn’t sustain it and was hoping to limit the damage the best he could. After all, he was in third in the supercross series and there’s a nice bonus for that. He had to race, it was that simple.
How many people knew that in the stands and even in the media? I can guarantee you not very many. If you follow the message boards, there was a little blurb on there but it was relegated to the second page very quickly. There was Jason Lawrence and conspiracy theories to talk about people! My point isn’t to toot my own horn because I did some digging and wrote about it in my “Observations” column, the real point is that it’s too bad our sport isn’t more open and forthcoming in its information. The riders don’t want to show any weakness and the teams often times are kept in the dark by the rider because A-he doesn’t want to miss races and not get that contract next year or B- The trainer tells him to keep it quiet because it’s none of the teams business. There is a prominent 450 rider right now that is in and out of the races because he’s battling an injury. He really shouldn’t be out there and his results show it, but his team is pressuring him to ride and he needs a deal for next year. After all if you pull out, the team will not want to hire a pussy to ride for them next season.
We get our information about the riders from the riders themselves and that seems a little backwards to me. We should have an open and honest flow of communication from the teams about what the riders tested that week, what’s hurting and how everything is going with the team. More information is power to the media and makes them want to write about what is going on. The buzz would escalate and we would see the results that coming weekend. Look at roadracing, they tell you they went for a tire test on a certain day, they tell you what special parts they are trying and when something blows up or a rider is on clearly inferior tires or bike, well they tell the media and nothing happens. There is no burning on the cross of the rider or the tire company, everyone acknowledges it and moves on.
In our sport Bridgestone tires are generally accepted as being a superior tire to anything else out there. That's not me making something up, thats coming off the record from guys that are riding or ridden with them. Look at all the top teams and riders using them and trust me when I say it’s not about the money. Bridgestone’s budget is nothing compared to Dunlops. There’s also Pirelli and they are a ways off in regards to a supercross spec tire. Yet, there is nothing ever said about anything, maybe we should be praising the ride of Ben Coisy of the Motoconcepts team with his Pirelli Honda CRF450 and the fact he’s in fifteenth in the series points with tires that I guarantee you are not as good as the guys to his right and left on the gate. Again, it’s no slam on Pirelli-they have World Championships up the wazoo and make a fine tire for anyone of us, it’s just that at the highest of skill levels, the tires (especially front) are a huge factor. Also Pirelli is new to the game (4 years) and is trying to compete with the years and years their competitiors have on them. If we were roadracing, we’d be saying that Coisy is doing fantastic with a privateer Honda and Pirelli tires. But instead, no one is talking about Ben at all.
I guess what I’m calling for is more transparency from the teams and riders to let the fans and media chatter amongst ourselves about the racers and machines. The old adage that the worse thing people can say about you (or your sport) is nothing at all applies here.




Comments
This is how is seams to go in a lot of sports. 20-25 years ago you could know more about the riders, bikes etc. because it was not such a "big" sport. The more money, sponsors & promotion leads to the "stakes" being higher. I think the higher stakes leads to less information being given freely. Everyone gets on the podium and thanks the fans. Weege can't get anything out of anyone in the press conference besides the ussaul "teams great, tires great...." stuff. No one wants to loose an edge, the higher the stakes the more scared everyone gets. Formula One is one of the most popular sports in the world but you cannot get any "details" about anything. Every mechanical is just that "a mechanical problem". Yes I wan't to know the details, the story, not just where everyone placed. This is why we turn to you Steve (all 10+ of us?), everyone else supplies the "surface", you get to the detials (more than most). Keep diging, good reading as allways.
Is pretty secretive you're right. But Moto GP is not or for that matter,almost all road racing. Pick up a Cycle News sometime, you'll learn a lot more about what the teams are testing and the riders think in that world. Also, I thought about this later-how come RR teams get busted for cheating here and there and there's no massive outcry? Does no one think any of the moto teams are cheating? Is it just that there are basically no fans of RR so no one cares...is there a Mototalk of RR? Do these guys burn the teams and riders at the stake for thier transgressions?
Things to think about..
Your right, its random. Moto GP is huge but they are much more transparent. When they test at a track there's daily reports, what tire did what, who's geometry was of etc. Oh what a great idea, MX / SX should have the same type of testing, everyone can go to the scheduled test track.... can you imagine that. Contrast to F1 everyone goes to the "allowed" test sessions, you get daily reports about ? - nothing really beyond lap times and hairdoo's. The cheating thing, so true, I remember there was a running series of articles in Cycle News last year (?) on somebody's crankshafts didn't have the right "production" codes or some such, and in the end they were illegal. The thing is I think if some rider / team was more open they would gain a following of fans maybe ?
I would love to receive more information from the Factories and their riders. Everything is so secretive and it sucks donkeys.
By the way, I would have guessed that the banner at the top would be a picture of Ferry and not Stewart. Where do your loyalties really lie?
Dear Tits, there's five rotating pictures up top.
1-CR
1-JS
1-RV
2-Red Dog...you should have known!
Greatest name ever by the way.
I'm pretty sure the banners are randomized. Hit refresh a few times and I'm sure Ferry will pop up there.
"it’s too bad our sport isn’t more open and forthcoming in its information"... I guess this never occured to me. It seems like we always know every little detail about why J-Law is slow, fast or not racing that week. There are just certain riders the media likes to talk about more than others. Short doesn't make any waves so he tends to fly under the radar. That's why he's running 3rd in points and he's hardly ever discussed. My guess is that if Chad or James tore a tricep you would hear about it. The team would want an excuse for any lack of performance.